Federal Style

Goodnow Farmhouse // c.1786

Buildings of New EnglandLeave a comment

Located in the bucolic town of Princeton, Massachusetts, Goodnow Farm sits at the heart of a landscape that has been farmed for more than two and a half centuries. The farm and road take their name from the Goodnow family who owned the land here for well over 100 years. The farmhouse, which dates to around 1786, was built for Edward Goodnow (1742-1798) and his wife Lois, who married in 1770. Edward was a corporal during the Revolution, serving both at the Lexington alarm on April 19, 1775, and at Dorchester Heights in 1776, before settling in Princeton to spend his remaining years on the farm. The property was inherited by his son, Edward and later by his son, William B. Goodnow (1815-1904), the brother of Edward Augustus Goodnow, a merchant who made his fortune in Worcester and donated the Town Hall and Library to his birthplace. After nearly 150 years of Goodnow family ownership, in 1917 the old farm was sold to industrialist, Charles T. Crocker, Jr. of Fitchburg and became a gentleman’s farm. Crocker used the farm as a summer retreat from the city and hired staff to maintain the working farm aesthetic, though Charles Crocker did not actually do much or any of the agricultural laboring himself. Investing in the old farm to maintain the rural charm, Crocker added a large cow barn and attached dairy and the estate managed livestock and orchards. After the death of his father, in 1956, Mr. Crocker’s son, Charles T. Crocker, III, gave the main part of the farm, in two parcels totaling 636 acres, to the Massachusetts Audubon Society, to be preserved in perpetuity as a wildlife sanctuary. He made an additional gift of 118 acres in 1963. Over the subsequent decades, other parcels were acquired and the site has been operated as the Wachusett Meadow Wildlife Sanctuary, covering roughly 1,100 acres of the oldest farmland in Princeton, with twelve miles of public walking trails and historic stone walls. The site preserves what early Princeton was known for, at a simpler time when families depended on their own gardens, orchards, livestock and labor.

Osgood Farmhouse // c.1794

Buildings of New England2 Comments

When the town of Princeton was incorporated, vast land holdings were acquired, sold, and subdivided into large farmsteads for families moving westward from Boston. Part of the land in present-day Princeton was owned by William Brattle of Cambridge, but was undeveloped and confiscated by the Government as Brattle was a Loyalist, and sold in 1781. The property was purchased by David Osgood and later inherited by his son, Houghton Osgood (1768-1844), who built this farmhouse around 1794. The farmhouse and surrounding property with small pond, remained in the Osgood family until the mid 20th century.

Abijah Moore Tavern – Locust Lawn // c.1750 & 1890

Buildings of New EnglandLeave a comment

A Colonial-era tavern that was Victorianized in the 19th century as a summer residence, only in New England! This stately mansion sits on Merriam Road in the charming town of Princeton, Massachusetts and was originally built by 1750 as a tavern/inn. Owner Abijah Moore (1724-1792) built the residence here as the road in front of his property was the main east-west highway between Lancaster and Barre, part of the Old Bay Path in the Commonwealth. When Princeton was first incorporated in 1759, it was in this house that the newly formed community held their first meetings. In 1765, Moore sold the property and moved to Vermont, and the Tavern became a farmhouse, renovated in the early 19th century with twin chimneys and barns behind. As Princeton shifted from agricultural to a summer colony, the property was purchased by Thomas Hastings Russell, who spent summers in his modified family homestead across the street. The traditional New England farmhouse was “modernized” in around 1890 with a full-length porch with corner gazebo and renamed Locust Lawn. The property was gifted to Thomas’ daughter, Mary, and her husband, Edward, as their own summer home.

Elisha Allen Farm – Nehemiah Parker Farmhouse // 1794

Buildings of New England1 Comment

In the summer of 1793, the quiet hill town of Princeton, Massachusetts, was shaken by a brutal murder that people were still discussing long afterward. Samuel Frost (1765-1793) was born in Princeton as one of three children. At 14, Samuel’s mother died after reportedly falling ill, but he blamed his father, who reportedly abused his mother for his entire childhood. On September 23, 1783, at the age of 18, Frost murdered his father while they were digging a ditch. Frost knocked his father over, and repeatedly stabbed him in the head with a handspike until his brains were exposed. Samuel Frost was tried in court for murdering his father but was acquitted on the grounds of insanity. Years later, Captain Elisha Allen (1744-1793), a Revolutionary War Veteran and farmer in Princeton, became the guardian of Samuel Frost, providing him housing and a job on his property. On July 16, 1793, during an argument in a field on his employer’s farm, Samuel Frost killed Captain Elisha Allen. In the trial, it was discovered that Frost struck Mr. Allen more than fifteen times with the blade of a hoe and left his body lying on the ground. This time there was no acquittal. At the trial, he was found sane and sentenced to death. He was executed on a hill in Worcester on October 31, 1793. Executions then drew huge crowds and a carnival-like atmosphere. Allen’s grave in Princeton’s old burying ground records that he was “foully murdered by Samuel Frost.” The old farm in Princeton was purchased a year after Elisha’s death by Nehemiah Parker, who built this brick Federal-era farmhouse in 1794. While the home is not tied directly to Captain Elisha Allen, it was upon the fields that he brutally lost his life and is forever tied to the property here.

Boylston Villa // 1819

Buildings of New England1 Comment

Ward Nicholas Boylston (1747-1828) was born as Ward Hallowell, in Jamaica Plain, Boston. At the age of 21, he took the name of his uncle, Nicholas Boylston, a wealthy Boston merchant who had no direct heir. A year later, he inherited his uncle’s estate and soon thereafter left for the next 27 years, taking up residence in London, and traveling across Europe and the Middle East. In 1800, Ward Nicholas Boylston inherited 3,000 acres of land from his uncle, Moses Gill, a wealthy merchant and acting Governor of Massachusetts from 1799 to 1800, when he died in office. Moses Gill was a slaveowner and when he moved to Princeton in 1767, town records indicate that he brought three “Negro servants” (slaves) with him. Interestingly, Gill thought enough of those whom he enslaved, as he bought expensive gravestones for their burial in the graveyard in Princeton, all three of which remain here to this day. They were: Nero, Flora, and Thomas. Ward Boylston spent summers at his uncle’s country estate until it was eventually demolished for his new Federal style country retreat, said to have been designed by Asher Benjamin, an architect then in the employ of Charles Bulfinch. The small brick villa is notable for its Palladian arches and walls inside lined with French Dufour wallpaper. Ward Nicholas Boylston’s name lives on through the names of Boylston Street in Boston named after him, as is the town of Boylston, Massachusetts, and Boylston Hall at Harvard University. He died in 1828 and was buried in the family tomb in Princeton. After his Nicholas’ widow, Alicia, died in 1843, the estate passed into the possession of Ward’s grandson, Dr. Ward Nicholas Boylston (1816-1870), who practiced medicine in Boston. Within a year after coming into his inheritance, the Dr. Boylston quit his career and settled at Boylston Villa, where he spent the remainder of his life and improved the estate with outbuildings.

Captain Benjamin Harrington House – Fernside // 1835

Buildings of New EnglandLeave a comment

Near the side of Mount Wachusett in Princeton, Massachusetts, Fernside has seen nearly two centuries of changing use but has maintained its significance all the while. This house was originally built in 1835 by Captain Benjamin Livermore Harrington (1774-1851) as a late example of a Federal style farmhouse with a symmetrical, five-bay facade and center entrance. Local resident, Wilkes Roper, bought the house in 1870 as the town of Princeton became desirable as a summer retreat, offering visitors cool mountain breezes and sweeping views of central Massachusetts. Mr. Roper added the side wings and opened the house as the Summer House Hotel, primarily renting rooms to Harvard professors and students. By 1890, the building had become the Vacation House for Working Girls. Renamed Fernside, the property became a resort for working women who could not otherwise have afforded a vacation. A week’s stay would have cost these ladies $4 in 1900. Guests arrived by train and were met by the Fernside carriage, which brought them and their luggage to the property. While staying here, the girls hiked the mountain, enjoyed fresh vegetables from the garden, and spent evenings in the library with charades, musicals, theatricals and dancing. Fernside’s final summer as a vacation house was 1988. Today, the property is home to Fernside at McLean, a rehabilitation center operated by McLean Hospital.

Howe-Muzzy-Parker House // 1822

Buildings of New EnglandLeave a comment

Once painted and now slowly returning to its former glory, the Joel Howe House on Merriam Road is an example of a typical middle-class residence of the early 19th century in the community of Princeton. Joel Howe (1797-1864) was formerly a resident of Holden and came to Princeton to marry Lydia Merriam, who’s family had lived in the town since 1788. Joel worked as a blacksmith and reportedly maintained his blacksmith shop in the house and barn built in 1822 and still standing nearby. The family would move to West Boylston and Joel would sell the property to a colleague, fellow blacksmith, Benjamin F. Muzzy (1828-1887). In the late 19th century, the old brick residence was owned by Dr. Charles Edward Parker a notable physician in town. In the 20th century, the house was painted, but is slowly being worn off by time, giving the house a sort of vitiligo effect.

Robinson Tavern // c.1796

Buildings of New EnglandLeave a comment

This stately Federal style residence with prominent Palladian window on its facade, is located on the edge of the Town Green in the idyllic village of Strafford, Vermont. The residence was built around 1796 and owned by Daniel Robinson (1735-1820), a cabinet maker, who resided here with his son, Zadock. The father-son business partners also appear to have operated the building as a tavern, with its important location as a stop along the route between Boston and Montpellier. The second floor of the residence was a “long room” for meetings and a ballroom. The large former tavern is now a private residence and retains much of its original character.

United Church of Strafford // 1832

Buildings of New England2 Comments

After the public support of religion ended in Vermont in 1807, when before this tax dollars were used to support the Congregational Church in towns and villages all over the state, many congregations split and erected their own purpose-built houses of worship. The Congregaional Church of Strafford was once located in the Strafford Meetinghouse, a 1799 structure at the edge of the town green. In 1832, the churches left the building, with the Unitarians building a church in the South Strafford Village, and Congregationalists building this church that same year. The old Congregational Church blends Federal and Greek Revival styles both in the vernacular, but it retains much of its original features. The Free Will Baptists sold their church building in the lower village (South Strafford) and the Baptists joined the Congregationalists to form the United Church of Strafford in 1967, occupying this church building.

Universalist Church of Strafford // 1833

Buildings of New England1 Comment

The Universalist Society of Strafford, founded in 1798, is the second oldest in Vermont and fourth oldest in the nation. In the early years, Universalists met in Strafford’s Town House, sharing the building with other denominations. Eventually the Universalists, Baptists, and Congregationalists all built their own churches, with the Universalists building this handsome structure in 1833 in the South Strafford Village. Blending late Federal and Greek Revival styles, the white clapboarded church is sited on a small hill and is characterized by its belfry and large stained glass windows.

Dr. Pierce House – Hazelton’s Hotel // 1821 & 1858

Buildings of New EnglandLeave a comment

Located on the edge of the Town Common in Strafford, Vermont, this Federal period residence was “modernized” decades after its completion for a new use. The house was originally built in 1821 by Dr. Albigence Pierce (1789-1873) for his wife and seven children with a small office alongside where he worked as the town’s primary physician. Dr. Pierce maintained his residence and office here until his retirement, when he moved back to Royalton, where he was born. He sold the main building to Lucius Carpenter in 1857, who opened a tavern and public hall a year later. In 1858, he updated the house, adding an ell on the rear for parties, meetings, and dances, and altered the roofline, adding a third floor with gable, bracketed eaves, and replaced all the windows with sashes of the period. The only Federal period detailing that remains is the traditional entrance with blind fan above the entry and three-light sidelights flanking. In 1859, Henry Hazelton married Carpenter’s daughter Amanda, and he would purchase the property from his father-in-law in 1865, operating it as Hazelton’s Hotel and Hall. By the 20th century, the property was converted back to a private residence.

Harris Store // 1833

Buildings of New England2 Comments

In 1833, Jedediah H. Harris, who had run a general store in Strafford village since 1805, commissioned a local contractor to build a new brick and granite store. The brick store was added onto the early 19th century wood-frame building. Harris and his business partner, Justin Morrill, opened the store in 1834, selling provisions to locals and visitors to the small town. Morrill would later go on to construct a stunning Gothic Revival style home nearby and become a leading U.S. Senator. For more than one hundred years the store passed through a succession of owners, until C. William Berghorn Jr. closed it in 1951 to make it his residence. The Greek Revival style building has since been converted to the local post office branch with the early wood-frame wing housing a local coffee shop/cafe.

Judge Cobb House // c.1807

Buildings of New EnglandLeave a comment

Located at the edge of the Town Common in Strafford, Vermont, this handsome Federal style residence dates to the early 19th century and has ties to a prominent local family. The house was built around 1807 and originally owned by a Benjamin Wood and by 1823, the property was owned by Daniel Cobb. Judge Daniel Cobb (1787-1868) served as the town’s Chief lawyer, Assistant Judge of Orange County Court, the town’s first postmaster, and as an elected representative to the state legislature. After his death, the property was inherited by Daniel’s son, Nathan Cobb (1827-1906), who was largely housebound from an injury while a student at Norwich University. Nathan Cobb became Strafford’s town clerk in 1863 and would hold that position for 43 years. He would also serve as the town treasurer, tax collector, school superintendent, and librarian. He housed the town’s library in the home for a number of decades and was also a justice of the peace and ran a printmaking business. Dr. Gardner Cobb, whose mother died shortly after his birth, was Nathan’s only child. He became a pediatrician and owned the house until his death in 1967. For 150 years, the house has been known as the Cobb House and is notable for its pressed metal roof.

Strafford Meetinghouse // 1799

Buildings of New England4 Comments

Perched atop a hill at the edge of the town common in Strafford, Vermont, the Strafford Meetinghouse exemplifies the traditional New England meetinghouse. The town of Strafford was settled in 1768 by settlers from Connecticut under a charter issued by the Governor of New York. Today, it may be best-known as the hometown of Noah Kahan. The meetinghouse was the first structure to be built in the present village and was constructed in a central position within the township on the turnpike between Montpelier and Boston. Built in 1799 by local carpenters, the structure served as a site for town meetings and house of worship for various congregations in the community. At the time of the disestablishment of the churches in Vermont in the early 19th century, many meetinghouses like in Strafford, passed to the possession of churches, however, both of the leading church groups in the town decided to build their own churches. As a result, the old Strafford Meetinghouse remained the property of the Town to accommodate local civic meetings. The exterior of the building is largely unchanged besides the addition of the tower and belfry on the primary facade in 1832. The building remains one of the finest and best-preserved examples of a 18th century meetinghouse in New England, and with its bucolic setting, it often serves as a backdrop and feature in photoshoots and New England travel publications.

Arnold–Palmer House // 1826

Buildings of New EnglandLeave a comment

The Arnold-Palmer House (no, it’s not named after the drink) can be found on Chestnut Street in Downtown Providence, Rhode Island, as a rare surviving Federal period residence to escape the fate of many buildings of the period there from commercialization and later urban renewal. The house was built in 1826 for wealthy Providence merchant Daniel Arnold at a location on upper Westminster Street near Cathedral Square, where it was one of four nearly identical houses whose design was attributed to prominent local architect John Holden Greene. Like many of Greene’s other Federal style designs, the Arnold-Palmer House exhibits a symmetrical primary facade, elaborate fanlight windows, and a monitor-on-hip-roof. The house was actually saved and moved to its present site (facing a surface parking lot) in the 1960s as part of the Weybosset Hill urban redevelopment project.